Why "The Quran Contradicts the Bible" Misreads the Bible One of the most common objections raised against the Quran is that it "contradicts the Bible." The Quran, the critic says, retells the stories of Adam, Noah, Abraham, Moses, and Jesus, but changes details, so it cannot be from God. The objection sounds forceful until you … Continue reading Bible Tradition of Retelling and Revision
A Calf That Lowed & Egyptian and Mesopotamian Mythology
The Quran's account of the golden calf includes a subtle detail that the Book of Exodus omits. The calf, we are told, was a body that made the sound of a calf. It is easy to read past this as a piece of narrative color, a miraculous flourish. It is anything but. To an audience … Continue reading A Calf That Lowed & Egyptian and Mesopotamian Mythology
The Last Pilgrim on the Throne
Harun al-Rashid and the Sovereign Who Stopped Going to Mecca An interesting paradox lies buried in the long history of the caliphate. The office existed, in part, to guard the Hajj—to protect the roads to Mecca, to provision the pilgrim caravans, to keep the sanctuary open to the community. Yet across nearly thirteen centuries and … Continue reading The Last Pilgrim on the Throne
The Offer Lot Already Knew Would Be Refused
When Lot stands at his door and offers his daughters to the crowd pressing toward his guests, most readers wince. Taken at face value, it reads as a father bartering his children to a mob. But the Quran does not leave the episode at face value. Read alongside the way scripture elsewhere shows the wise … Continue reading The Offer Lot Already Knew Would Be Refused
Would God Command Genocide?
The Hebrew Bible contains a handful of passages that are hard to read and harder to defend. Moses orders that no one among the Midianites be spared except the young girls (Numbers 31). Joshua devotes whole cities to destruction, "man and woman, young and old" (Joshua 6). Saul is told to strike Amalek and kill … Continue reading Would God Command Genocide?
The Modes of Divine Disclosure
The Quran does not describe God as one object set among other objects. It presents Him as the Absolute in relation to which every object is measured, named, and known. And yet the same book that insists there is nothing whatsoever like Him also speaks of Him ceaselessly—as One who wills, speaks, commands, sends, draws … Continue reading The Modes of Divine Disclosure
Three False Equivalences in the Defense of Hadith
When Sunnis diminish the Quran to elevate the Hadith When traditionalists are challenged on the authenticity, reliability, or internal consistency of the Hadith corpus, the response often shifts away from defending those problems on their own terms. Instead, the discussion shifts to a challenge to the Quran: it too is said to produce disagreements, contain … Continue reading Three False Equivalences in the Defense of Hadith
Between Two Banks: The River as Threshold in the Quran
In January of 49 BCE, a Roman general paused on the northern bank of an unremarkable stream. The Rubicon was shallow enough to wade and narrow enough to be overlooked by geography, but it marked the legal boundary of Italy proper—the line beyond which a commander was forbidden to lead an army under arms. To … Continue reading Between Two Banks: The River as Threshold in the Quran
Forty Years: The Prophecy of the Temple’s Fall
In the final week of his public life, Jesus stood with his disciples on the Mount of Olives, looking across the Kidron Valley toward the most magnificent building any of them would have seen in their lives. Herod's Temple was still under construction, a project decades in the making, its retaining walls built from limestone … Continue reading Forty Years: The Prophecy of the Temple’s Fall
The Purpose We Forgot
There is a way of reading the fall of man that has almost nothing to do with fruit. We tend to imagine the first failure as an act of appetite—a reaching hand, a forbidden taste, desire overrunning a command. But when the Quran narrates the moment, it reaches for a different word, and the word … Continue reading The Purpose We Forgot
Quran Talk Blog 