Quote Mining the Orientalists: How Hadith Apologists Palter with Western Scholarship

A familiar move has become popular among Sunni traditionalist apologists online. Having spent decades dismissing Western academic study of hadith as "Orientalist" hostility, some now cite that same scholarship as a witness for the defense. The claim runs something like this: the consensus of Western scholarship is that the Companions wrote down the hadith—therefore the … Continue reading Quote Mining the Orientalists: How Hadith Apologists Palter with Western Scholarship

Did the Seven Canonical Quranic Reciters Agree on the Basmalah?

Abū ʿAmr al-Dānī (371–444 AH / 981–1053 CE) was an influential Andalusian scholar of Qur'anic recitation. His al-Taysīr fī al-Qirāʾāt al-Sabʿ (The Facilitation of the Seven Readings) became one of the foundational works on the seven canonical reading traditions (qirāʾāt) of the Quran. RegionReaderFirst TransmitterSecond TransmitterMedinaNāfiʿ (d. 169 AH / 785 CE)Qālūn (d. ca. 220 … Continue reading Did the Seven Canonical Quranic Reciters Agree on the Basmalah?

Hasan al-Basri’s Risala fi al-Qadar: Why Did He Cite the Quran but No Hadith?

Sometime during the latter half of the reign of the Umayyad caliph ʿAbd al-Malik ibn Marwān (685–705 CE / 65–86 AH), ruler of an empire stretching from Central Asia to North Africa, he wrote to a preacher in Basra. The caliph had heard that Hasan al-Basri was teaching something about qadar that no one had … Continue reading Hasan al-Basri’s Risala fi al-Qadar: Why Did He Cite the Quran but No Hadith?

The Hebrew Root of Muhammad’s Name in the Bible: Song of Solomon 5:16 and Haggai 2:7

The name Muhammad comes from the Arabic root ḥ-m-d, which carries the sense of praise. Muhammad literally means either the "praised one" or the "one who praises," and the Quran also records the related name Aḥmad, "most praised." In sura 61, Jesus tells the Children of Israel that he brings good news of a messenger … Continue reading The Hebrew Root of Muhammad’s Name in the Bible: Song of Solomon 5:16 and Haggai 2:7

When the Companions Disagreed: A Reference of Recorded Disputes in the Hadith Corpus

The hadith literature is usually presented as a record of what the Companions heard, saw, and practiced in the presence of the Prophet. Yet the same books preserve a large body of material in which Companions contradict, correct, rebuke, or flatly reject one another on questions of law, practice, and belief. These disputes are not … Continue reading When the Companions Disagreed: A Reference of Recorded Disputes in the Hadith Corpus