From Ibn Taymiyyah to ISIS: The Intellectual Genealogy of Salafi-Jihadism

Salafism is a broad family of Muslim movements that seek to ground belief and practice in the example of the salaf, the first three generations of Islam: the Prophet Muhammad's companions and the two generations after them. Most Salafis are not violent. Many are politically passive. However, Salafi-jihadism is a small, militant offshoot, but it … Continue reading From Ibn Taymiyyah to ISIS: The Intellectual Genealogy of Salafi-Jihadism

From Islamic Modernism to Salafism: How a Reform Movement Changed Direction

In 1798, a French army landed in Egypt and took the country in a matter of weeks. For Muslims across the Ottoman world, the shock was not only military. The empire that had besieged Vienna a little over a century earlier now could not defend one of its richest provinces from a European expeditionary force … Continue reading From Islamic Modernism to Salafism: How a Reform Movement Changed Direction

Bukhari Transmitted From A Knwon Fabricator: Ismāʿīl ibn Abī Uways and the Limits of Bukhārī’s Rigor

For Sunni traditionalists, Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī is the most authentic book after the Quran. That status rests on one claim: that al-Bukhārī admitted only narrators who passed the strictest screening, a screening carried out through the science of narrator criticism (ʿilm al-rijāl). The chain of transmission is supposed to be the safeguard, and al-Bukhārī is supposed … Continue reading Bukhari Transmitted From A Knwon Fabricator: Ismāʿīl ibn Abī Uways and the Limits of Bukhārī’s Rigor

Quote Mining the Orientalists: How Hadith Apologists Palter with Western Scholarship

A familiar move has become popular among Sunni traditionalist apologists online. Having spent decades dismissing Western academic study of hadith as "Orientalist" hostility, some now cite that same scholarship as a witness for the defense. The claim runs something like this: the consensus of Western scholarship is that the Companions wrote down the hadith—therefore the … Continue reading Quote Mining the Orientalists: How Hadith Apologists Palter with Western Scholarship

Did the Seven Canonical Quranic Reciters Agree on the Basmalah?

Abū ʿAmr al-Dānī (371–444 AH / 981–1053 CE) was an influential Andalusian scholar of Qur'anic recitation. His al-Taysīr fī al-Qirāʾāt al-Sabʿ (The Facilitation of the Seven Readings) became one of the foundational works on the seven canonical reading traditions (qirāʾāt) of the Quran. RegionReaderFirst TransmitterSecond TransmitterMedinaNāfiʿ (d. 169 AH / 785 CE)Qālūn (d. ca. 220 … Continue reading Did the Seven Canonical Quranic Reciters Agree on the Basmalah?

Hasan al-Basri’s Risala fi al-Qadar: Why Did He Cite the Quran but No Hadith?

Sometime during the latter half of the reign of the Umayyad caliph ʿAbd al-Malik ibn Marwān (685–705 CE / 65–86 AH), ruler of an empire stretching from Central Asia to North Africa, he wrote to a preacher in Basra. The caliph had heard that Hasan al-Basri was teaching something about qadar that no one had … Continue reading Hasan al-Basri’s Risala fi al-Qadar: Why Did He Cite the Quran but No Hadith?